I borrowed the picture from the Guardian, via Google |
When I first
read headlines about liquid nitrogen in cocktails, I thought the media had gone
mad. Nitrogen is liquid at almost 200 degrees below zero. Above that
temperature it becomes gas.
Liquid
Nitrogen has many uses, but one example is in the NHS where it is used to
freeze warts, that gives an idea how cold it is. There is no way you can drink
it. Pour it into your mouth and your lips and tongue would freeze solid. If you
did get it into your stomach, it would explode because of the rapidly expanding
gas.
That is not
what happened to the poor girl who lost her stomach; she didn’t explode on the spot or
freeze her mouth solid.
As far as I
can work out, these cocktails have a small amount of liquid nitrogen added,
which rapidly evaporates, making an interesting mist and adding to the drama of
the drink. So why is it dangerous?
That's where
the physics comes in.
If you add
alcohol to water, it lowers the freezing point. The more alcohol you add then
the lower the temperature you need in order to freeze the mixture.
Most
cocktails have between 15% and 40% alcohol, which means that it would not turn
into ice cubes unless you got it below the temperature that you find in most
domestic freezers.
The table
shows the freezing point of alcohol water mixtures.
Alcohol
Concentration
|
10%
|
20%
|
30%
|
40%
|
50%
|
Freezing point
Centigrade
|
-4
|
-9
|
-15
|
-23
|
-32
|
Next
question, how do they make these cocktails? I am surprised that the media don't
seem to provide details, but from what I've seen, the barman makes up the
cocktail and tips a little liquid nitrogen into the mixture.
That will
cool the cocktail; exactly how cold it gets will depend on the temperature that
it started at and how much liquid nitrogen is tipped in.
When you mix
something that is at minus 190 degrees with something that has just come out of
the fridge behind the bar, the final temperature depends on the volume of the
two quantities that are mixed. The average cocktail is around 100-125 ml. Cocktail
mixing is not an exact science but on average, something like a teaspoonful of
liquid nitrogen would drop the temperature of the cocktail to about minus 15
degrees.
If you stuck
your fingers in it, you would rapidly get frostbite. Bang down a couple of
those cocktails and there is a good chance that your stomach gets frostbite. In
other words, chunks of the stomach lining would freeze solid and die. The next
thing you know you are in hospital having a gastrectomy.
Why the
stomach, rather than the mouth or the gullet? I think the answer is that the
fluid goes through those parts quite quickly, not allowing enough time for
significant heat transfer to happen. In the stomach, on the other hand, the
fluid stops moving and sits there doing damage. It won’t take long.
There will
obviously be demands that such drinks be banned. That is probably not
necessary, they can be made safe just by training the barman to use only
minimal amounts of nitrogen and checking the temperature. If the drink is more
than a few degrees below freezing, then don’t drink it. Not even if your
friends dare you.
If you must
drink one of these try asking the barman if he has 'O' level physics, but anyway take
your time, pose a lot, sip it slowly and if you want to be really safe, drink a
pint of warm beer first.
Thank you for explaining the science, I did wonder about this story. Poor girl.
ReplyDelete